Grand Valley State University | Lakers | A | 4 | Sarah Corder '23 | | Audrey Whitaker '23 | |
| | Jillian Greene '22 | |
Hillsdale College | Chargers | A | 1 | Arden Carleton '26 | | Alya MacManaway '26 | 1-2,5-6,9-10 |
| | Matthew Scanlon '25 | |
| | Riley Hamilton '25 | 3-4,7-8 |
Hope College | Flying Dutchmen | A | 5 | Jack Rutherford '25 | 1-2,5-6 | Gabriella Thomas '25 | 1-6,9-10 |
Connor Bricco '26 | 3-4,7-8 | Connor Bricco '26 | 1-2,5-6 |
Jennifer Falkner '24 | 9-10 | Kate Hutchinson '24 * | 3-4,7-10 |
| | Jack Rutherford '25 | 7-8 |
Indiana University | Hoosiers | A | 2 | Peter Grumbling '23 | | Julia Grumbling '26 | |
| | Taylor Longhitano '23 | |
Miami University | Red Hawks | A | 3 | Margaret Swasey '23 | | Jacob Maher '22 | |
| | AJ McRitchie '22 | |