| American University | Eagles | A | 6 | Cala Coffman '21 | | Fan Tai Bridges '21 | |
| B | 3 | John Spiccioli '22 | | Marty Isaacson '22 | 1-2 |
| | Charles Degen '23 | 3-4 |
| Catholic University of America | Cardinals | A | 4 | Clare Wagner '22 | | Maureen McGarry '21 | |
| B | 5 | Chris Lukas '21 | 1-2 | Ryan Delaney '22 | |
| Alex Walters '22 | 3-4 | | |
| St. John's College | Johnnies | A | 9 | Brooke Murphy-Petri '23 | | Katherine Quinn '22 | |
| B | 8 | John Monday '19 | | Jonah Donis '23 | |
| University of Maryland | Terrapins | A | 7 | Ryan Dorsey '20 | | Anna O'Connell '22 | |
| B | 4 | Michal Tyrlik '20 | | Elizabeth Keller '22 | |
| University of Virginia | Hoos | A | 3 | Matthew Weisenfluh '20 | | Kieran McMahon '22 | 1-2 |
| | Caroline O'Keeffe '21 | 3-4 |
| B | 1 | Emma Sullivan '23 | | Helen Bechler '22 | |
| Reserves | Katie Purcell '20 |
| Virginia Tech | Fighting Gobblers | A | 2 | Christopher Magno '22 | | Griffin Wagner '23 | |
| B | 7 | David Fehrle '21 | | Jackson Livanec '21 | |
| Washington College | Shoremen | A | 8 | Gage Mandrell '23 * | | Andrew Tran '23 | |
| B | 9 | Jonathan Kelly '23 * | | John Mecca '21 | |
| William and Mary | Tribe | A | 5 | Audrey Fulk '19 | | Michael Gibson '23 * | |
| B | 6 | Daisy Griffin '23 * | | Mariah Lee '22 | |
| William and Mary | Griffin | A | 1 | Constantyn van der Voort '23 | | Gabrielle Buffaloe '23 | |
| B | 2 | Nathan Whisner '23 | | Emma Powers '23 * | |
