| Round 1 |
|---|
| 1 |  | Washington College Shoremen | 1-2-4 | vs | 3-5-6 | Hampton University Pirates |  |
| 2 |  | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | George Washington University Colonials |  |
| 3 |  | Cornell University Big Red | 4-5-6 | vs | 1-2-3 | Hobart and William Smith Colleges Statesmen |  |
| 4 |  | U. S. Merchant Marine Academy Mariners | 1-2-3 | vs | 4-5-6 | Christopher Newport University Captains |  |
| 5 | | Washington College Shoremen | 3-4-6 | vs | 1-2-5 | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | |
| 6 | | Hobart and William Smith Colleges Statesmen | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | Hampton University Pirates | |
| 7 | | Christopher Newport University Captains | 2-4-6 | vs | 1-3-5 | George Washington University Colonials | |
| 8 | | U. S. Merchant Marine Academy Mariners | 3-4-6 | vs | 1-2-5 | Cornell University Big Red | |
| 9 | | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | 3-4-6 | vs | 1-2-5 | Hobart and William Smith Colleges Statesmen | |
| 10 | | Washington College Shoremen | 1-4-5 | vs | 2-3-6 | Christopher Newport University Captains | |
| 11 | | Cornell University Big Red | 1-2-6 | vs | 3-4-5 | Hampton University Pirates | |
| 12 | | U. S. Merchant Marine Academy Mariners | 3-4-6 | vs | 1-2-5 | George Washington University Colonials | |
| 13 | | Christopher Newport University Captains | 3-4-6 | vs | 1-2-5 | Hobart and William Smith Colleges Statesmen | |
| 14 | | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | 2-3-4 | vs | 1-5-6 | Cornell University Big Red | |
| 15 | | George Washington University Colonials | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | Washington College Shoremen | |
| 16 | | U. S. Merchant Marine Academy Mariners | 1-2-4 | vs | 3-5-6 | Hampton University Pirates | |
| 17 | | Cornell University Big Red | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | Christopher Newport University Captains | |
| 18 | | Hobart and William Smith Colleges Statesmen | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | George Washington University Colonials | |
| 19 | | Hampton University Pirates | 2-3-5 | vs | 1-4-6 | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | |
| 20 | | Washington College Shoremen | 1-2-4 | vs | 3-5-6 | U. S. Merchant Marine Academy Mariners | |
| 21 | | George Washington University Colonials | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | Cornell University Big Red | |
| 22 | | Christopher Newport University Captains | 1-5-6 | vs | 2-3-4 | Hampton University Pirates | |
| 23 | | Hobart and William Smith Colleges Statesmen | 2-5-6 | vs | 1-3-4 | Washington College Shoremen | |
| 24 | | U. S. Merchant Marine Academy Mariners | 1-5-6 | vs | 2-3-4 | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | |
| 25 | | Hampton University Pirates | 3-4-5 | vs | 1-2-6 | George Washington University Colonials | |
| 26 | | Washington College Shoremen | 1-5-6 | vs | 2-3-4 | Cornell University Big Red | |
| 27 | | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | 1-4-5 | vs | 2-3-6 | Christopher Newport University Captains | |
| 28 | | U. S. Merchant Marine Academy Mariners | 3-4-6 | vs | 1-2-5 | Hobart and William Smith Colleges Statesmen | |
