| Christopher Newport University | Captains | A | 3 | Annie Eckmann '14 | | Julia Davis '16 | |
| B | 3 | Victoria Miller '13 | | Faith Swan '15 | |
| Christopher Newport University | Captains Blue | A | 4 | Mary Buhl '14 | | Shelby Locke '16 | |
| B | 1 | Grace Bluefeld '15 | | Kayla Harper '16 | |
| Columbia University | Lions | A | 5 | Catherine Thies '16 | | Alison Rosenfeld '13 | |
| B | 7 | Laura Maranto '14 | | Catherine Duggan '15 | |
| Cornell University | Big Red | A | 1 | Quinn Howes '16 | | Erin Ahlers '13 | |
| B | 2 | Lindsey Ludwig '14 | | Rebecca Macies '14 | |
| George Washington University | Colonials | A | 2 | Hannah McNomee '16 | 1-7 | Alix Suter '16 | 1-7 |
| B | 5 | Madeline Taggart '15 | 1-7 | Skye Kussman '13 | 1-7 |
| Rebecca Engel '13 | 8-14 | Meagan Murphy '15 | 8-14 |
| William and Mary | Tribe | A | 6 | Delaney Osborn '13 | 1-7 | Cynthia Ciccotelli '16 | 1-7 |
| B | 4 | Kaitlynn Menoche '15 | 1-7 | Ella Cahill '15 | 1-7 |
| William and Mary | Griffin | A | 7 | Amanda Castagna '15 | | Alexandra Rosenbluth '15 | |
| B | 6 | Rachel Pinkham '16 | | Cassidy Fazio '15 | |