| Christopher Newport University | Captains 1 | A | 7 | Amanda Attardi '17 | | Hanna Halleck-Pinkleton '18 | |
| B | 8 | Anders Hudson '17 | | Alexis Noell '18 | 1-12 |
| | Hannah Cantolino '18 | 13-16 |
| Christopher Newport University | Captains 2 | A | 10 | Andrew Hall '17 | | Kaitlyn Reilly '18 | |
| B | 13 | Shelby Locke '16 | | Benjamin Kempton '18 | |
| Hampton University | Pirates | A | 2 | Veronica Maccari '17 | | Cristina Ortiz Vivas '18 | |
| B | 5 | Maximilian Kuester '18 | | Albert Berk Toledo '15 | |
| Old Dominion University | Monarchs 1 | A | 3 | Jason Bankert '18 | | Travis Carlisle '17 | |
| B | 1 | Jeremy Herrin '18 | | Katelyn Talley '16 | |
| Old Dominion University | Monarchs 2 | A | 4 | Lee Dumaliang '17 | | Carter Little '18 | |
| B | 6 | Alec Chicoine '18 | | Kaylie Gallagher '16 | |
| St. John's College | Johnnies | A | 16 | Zeke Schumacher '15 | 1-8,13-16 | Maxwell Swann '17 | 1-2,5-8 |
| Caitriona O'Connor '18 | 9-12 | Caitriona O'Connor '18 | 3-4 |
| | Elijah Olegnowicz '18 | 9-16 |
| B | 15 | Branham Talton '15 | 1-2,5-8,13-16 | Elijah Olegnowicz '18 | 1-2 |
| Nicole Pease '15 | 3-4,9-12 | Allie Matheu '18 | 3-4,9-12 |
| | Calida Howell '18 | 5-8,13-16 |
| University of Virginia | Wahoos | A | 11 | Rodman Brown '16 | | Fritz Steuer '18 | |
| B | 12 | Callie Hern '18 | | Colleen Roney '18 | |
| William and Mary | Tribe | A | 9 | Samuel Keesee '17 | | Elizabeth Kelley '17 | |
| B | 14 | Elizabeth Ransone '18 | | Kelvin Abrokwa-Johnson '17 | |
