American Eagles | A | 4 | Peter Hays '14 | | Sarah Kreshtool '12 | |
B | 9 | Adam Taube '14 | | Emily Dube '15 | 1-3 |
| | BEATRIZ GIMENEZ DE CORDOBA '11 | 4-6 |
Christopher Newport Captains | A | 6 | Mary Buhl '14 | | Grace Bluefeld '15 | |
B | 4 | Annie Eckmann '14 | | Amy Craven '13 | |
George Washington Colonials | A | 2 | Andrew Beckmann '15 | | Erin McCormack '14 | |
B | 8 | Richard Sant '13 | | Sarah McCormack '14 | |
Hampton Pirates | A | 5 | Giuditta Di Laghi '16 | | Joshua Gopeesingh '14 | 1-2 |
| | Albert Berk Toledo '15 | 3-6 |
B | 5 | Kimannee Simon '14 | | CORTNAE JUSTICE '15 | 1-3 |
| | Joshua Gopeesingh '14 | 4-6 |
Salisbury Salisbury | A | 7 | Shaylyn Leary '12 | | Molly Graham '14 | |
B | 7 | Ryan Gallagher '13 | | | |
St. John's Johnnies | A | 9 | MaryEllen Markuske '15 | 1-4 | Leila Saad '15 | 1-2,5-6 |
Sean Sabella '14 | 5-6 | Sean Sabella '14 | 3-4 |
B | 6 | Branham Talton '15 | | Nicole Pease '15 | 1-3 |
| | Lawrence Leibowitz '14 | 4-6 |
Maryland Terps | A | 8 | Yusuf Hafez '13 | 1-2,5-6 | Elizabeth Lemanski '14 | |
Andrew Rybczynski '12 | 3-4 | | |
B | 3 | Sarah Hamm '13 | | Abigail Lundahl '15 | |
Virginia Wahoos | A | 1 | Christopher Stessing '14 | | Alexandra Brenin '15 | |
B | 1 | Madeline Gill '12 | | Hannah Varden '15 | 1-4 |
| | Ellen Hubbard '14 | 5-6 |
William and Mary Tribe | A | 3 | Isaac Clark '12 | | Derrill Hagood '13 | |
B | 2 | Andrew Bryan '13 | | Delaney Osborn '13 | |