| 1 |  | College of Charleston | | 1 | Christophe Killian '18 | | |
| Cougars | John Thompson '18 | | |
| Laura Masterson '20 | | |
| Howard Meyers '17 | | |
| 2 |  | University of South Florida | | 2 | Sean Cornell '18 | | |
| Bulls | Brendan Feeney '18 | | |
| Scott Ewing '18 | | |
| Mandi Dickie '18 | | |
| 3 |  | Jacksonville University | | 3 | Alfonso Garcia Bringas '20 | | |
| Fins | Andre Guaragna '20 | | |
| Hunter Skinner '20 | | |
| Lauri Niklason '17 * | | |
| 4 |  | Eckerd College | | 4 | Andrew Schoene '18 | | |
| Tritons | Jason D'Agostino '17 | | |
| Jamie Johar '19 | | |
| Matthew Peterson '18 | | |
